“And it’s not surprising then they get bitter, they cling to guns or religion or antipathy to people who aren’t like them or anti-immigrant sentiment or anti-trade sentiment as a way to explain their frustrations.”
Unlike previous controversies in Barack Obama’s campaign, this one comes from his own mouth. The previous speed-bumps that Obama has endured came from his surrogates or affiliations. Tony Rezko and Jeremiah Wright are different people with different agendas, but now for the first time, there is nobody to point the finger at except for Obama himself.
What’s most surprising is that this is Obama’s strong suit. It’s remarkable that with as many speeches as he’s done since the campaign began he hasn’t had a single major speaking meltdown like this. Perhaps the hectic schedule of the trail produced an aberrant “mis-speaking,” when he was tired or distracted, but there’s really no excuse for this.
Now, I’m not a swing voter in Pennsylvania and I’m the farthest thing from a hardcore Republican, but his statement offended me on a number of levels.
1. Barack mocked people of faith by claiming that they cling to religion in order to deal with their economic woes. Whether I’m broke like I am now or I was in the lucky group of people benefiting from Bush’s tax cuts, I would still believe in God. Even though our culture has come to worship consumerism, there are still a great number of devout Christians and Catholics in this country, and Obama just dissed them.
2. Obama takes a jab at every non CEO in the country when he talks about anti-trade sentiment in the same vein as racism. Let me tell you something, if Barack Obama lost his job as Senator to a 15 year old kid in India who will be getting paid not even a tenth as much as him, he would have some anti-trade sentiment as well. This is Obama’s greatest flaw: he has built a campaign on populism and the will of the people, yet he supports free trade at every opportunity. Free trade is a nice phrase, but the American people are learning what it really means. We are starting to understand that free trade isn’t about just competing in global markets; it’s about allowing companies free reign to do whatever they want. I can’t think of a more disastrous policy for the will of the people. The blue collar towns of Pennsylvania know what free trade is all about, and pardon me, but they have every right to be opposed to it, considering it’s one of the reasons they’re “bitter” in the first place.
3. The speech was made to a private crowd in San Francisco. In the 1850’s, Obama could have gotten away with pandering to this group, because people on the other side of the nation would have never heard about it. But he made a big mistake by playing to the prejudices of big city liberals. This provides the Republicans with elitist ammunition- now they can claim, nay, they can PROVE, that Barack Obama is out of touch with working class Americans and people of faith.
Obama seems to have forgotten that he has to try to please everybody all the time; statements like these put him into a corner. Even if he really feels this way about the people of small town Pennsylvania, he never should have said it like that. As slick of a politician as he is, he forgot what he’s supposed to do:
“You know, I’m a voter. Aren’t you supposed to lie to me and kiss my butt?” -Bill Murray, Ghostbusters